On my holiday in India I finally took some time to read. I bought two books, quite different in their message. One was the very well-known `Wikinomics’ by Don Tapscott & Anthony D. Williams. In a nutshell: Hallelujah web 2.0. Power to the people!
The other one I picked up from the bookshelves was `The cult of the amateur’ by Andrew Keen. His position (on the front cover): 2.0 is `killing our culture and assaulting our economy’.

I bought this book on purpose, to get some counterbalance for my positive vision on the rise of influence on the world by ordinary people because of the Internet.
In the first seven chapters of the book Keen talks about the internet as some plague that has come to destroy our world. The bottomline: Web 2.0 is destroying creativity and knowledge. What’s the use of getting a long education as an artist or scholar if everybody `steals’ all the work they have invested lots of money and time in anyway?
During the whole book I kept thinking `Mr. Keen, the world has changed. You can’t turn back time. Face it’. One of the many examples: Mr Keen blames universities for the many poker-addicted students, because they installed broadband internet in dorm rooms. That is just crazy, in my opinion!
And especially I kept thinking: What do you propose?
In the last chapter this becomes clear: a strict enforcing of copyright laws. And discipline by the people: stop copying music and pay for a subscription to a newspaper to guarantee independent and informed press.
Finally Keen offers some interesting ideas after all: more initiatives that mix content by experts with content from amateurs, or websites that have an expert panel that can `guarantee’ quality. I strongly agree with this!
Keen has given me food for thought. Many of the examples he gave were interesting and sometimes shocking. But this book has not changed my general idea at all, as I expected: the 6 billion people on this planet are perfectly capable of making their own decisions and cooperating with each other to make better things than we are offered now by big institutions and companies.
But perhaps I am just a hopeless optimist.
Tags: